From classic to contemporary: how to upgrade your engagement ring

Collaborative Post | An engagement ring isn't just a piece of jewellery; it's a symbol of a deep love and commitment that many proudly cherish.

Over time, personal styles change, fashion trends shift, or significant milestones may prompt a desire to refresh these much-loved pieces. Many beautiful engagement rings are often passed down through generations, with each new owner honouring their rich history, while adding their own personal flourish.  
​
For those contemplating this elegant evolution, the journey of transforming a classic engagement ring into a contemporary masterpiece can be both thrilling and daunting. From subtle changes to complete transformations, let's explore what upgrading an engagement ring means, how it’s done, and the key things to consider throughout the process. 

Photo by Gladys Aguayo on Unsplash

What does 'upgrading' mean?

An engagement ring upgrade is a lovely way to refresh and enhance your existing ring, which can happen in different ways.
​
It can mean swapping out the original gemstone for a bigger or different one, updating the setting, or adding extra sparkle with new design touches. Sometimes people change the metal or the style to give their ring a fresh, modern look while still keeping the sentimental value of the original piece.

Many couples choose to upgrade their ring to celebrate special moments like anniversaries, or simply because their tastes have changed over time. It’s a personal and meaningful way to keep the ring feeling as special and unique as the relationship it represents.

Why do people upgrade their engagement rings?

While celebrating an anniversary is a popular choice, it's definitely not the only one. The reasons behind the decision to upgrade an engagement ring can be incredibly diverse.
Here are just a few reasons why couples might consider making changes: 

• Celebrating milestones: Birthdays, anniversaries, or welcoming a new family member.
• Reflecting commitment: A celebration of personal growth, continued connection and shared accomplishment for the couple.   
• Evolving style: Personal tastes change, leading to a desire for a refreshed engagement ring.
• Improved finances: Enhanced budgets allow for more elaborate rings with features like side stones or a larger centre diamond.
• Fashion trends: New trends, like an oval cut engagement ring or toi et moi rings, might inspire an upgrade.

​
Ultimately, whether driven by life changes, improved finances, or a desire for a refreshed style, an upgraded ring reflects growth and shared experiences within a relationship.

Key things to consider

Whether it's a subtle adjustment or a transformation, understanding the options available can help you make an informed decision. Considerations such as incorporating original gemstones or opting for a new design can ensure the ring remains close to your heart.

1. Get your ring appraised:

Before you even consider an upgrade, it’s essential to get your engagement ring appraised. Appraisals are carried out by specialists and will include a detailed description of your ring, including weight, materials, gemstone quality, and craftsmanship. This helps to determine its current market value and allows you to make an informed decision about any of the style changes you want to add. 

Here's why an appraisal matters:

1. Financial value: An appraisal provides a precise selling value, so you know what to expect financially when trading in your ring.
2. Sentimental value: Ensures that any modifications made do not diminish the emotional significance of your precious jewellery.
3. Professional insight: Reputable jewellers offer accurate assessments, unlike personal guesses, which can lead to underestimations.
4. Insurance requirement: If you have insurance, your provider may require a certified appraisal to ensure full coverage.

Most jewellers provide appraisal services to ensure your ring’s worth is properly evaluated. Before you make any new design choices, be sure to request a certified appraisal so you have everything you need to make informed decisions about your new design choices. 

2. Work with a specialist jeweller:

While many jewellers are incredibly proficient in upgrading rings, some designs can sometimes be difficult to work with and may require a specialist jeweller, depending on what kind of work you would like to have done. 

For example, vintage rings often feature intricate and unique designs from a specific period. Some changes may not work well with the aesthetic or style of the time or could even compromise the integrity of the ring. 

Cluster engagement rings, which group smaller stones tightly together to create the illusion of a larger stone, can also be a challenge. Changing the centre stone or increasing its size could require a complete redesign of the setting. Similarly, halo engagement rings with intricate pavé or milgrain details around the centre stone can be incredibly hard to modify. 

That’s why working with a specialist can make all the difference. Their deep knowledge and craftsmanship will help guide you to ensure that your piece perfectly matches your personal taste and lifestyle. 

3. Set a realistic budget:

​Establishing a realistic budget is crucial when planning an upgrade. The cost will vary based on factors like the complexity of the design and the materials used. Gathering quotes from several jewellers can help manage and anticipate any financial concerns.

If you already have a budget in mind, talk it through with your jeweller. This communication will help them determine feasible options that respect your budget and help to align with your style choices. 

4. Subtle enhancements vs. complete makeovers

When it comes to upgrading, it's important to have a clear idea of what you're looking for. Subtle enhancements can be as simple as adding a wed-fit band, which offers a seamless fit without altering the original ring, or choosing to swap out the band for one with intricate designs, which can refresh the ring’s look while keeping the centre stone intact.

For those seeking a more transformational change, upgrading the diamond by increasing its size or quality provides a complete makeover. This change significantly boosts the ring's luxury and brilliance, but may require more work. 

If you’re unsure, always discuss your ideas with your jeweller. They’ll be able to provide exceptional guidance, and can even sketch out options for you so you can visualise your designs in great detail.    

Popular upgrade options

Updating an engagement ring can breathe new life into a cherished piece of jewellery. From enhancing the centre stone to altering the setting, there are many ways to upgrade while preserving its sentimental value. 

This allows you to keep the heart of the original ring while giving it a refreshed look. Popular options range from adding accent stones to changing the band material. By customising these elements, you create a unique piece that tells your personal love story.

1. Changing the centre stone:

One of the most popular ways to upgrade an engagement ring is by changing the centre stone. This can involve replacing the original gem with a larger or higher-quality diamond or gemstone. 

Opting for a different shape can further distinguish your ring. Some people choose lab-grown diamonds for cost-effective and eco-friendly options. When upgrading the centre stone, consider factors like cut, colour, clarity, and carat weight to achieve the perfect look.

2. Altering the setting:

Altering the setting preserves the sentimental value of the original centre stone while refreshing the ring's appearance. This can involve a change in the metal type, from rose gold to platinum, or updating the prong and bezel settings.

One choice could include an upgrade from a classic solitaire to a more intricate halo setting. Another option is incorporating the stone into a new design, such as a Toi et Moi or three-stone ring. Adding hidden elements, like gemstones beneath the centre stone, can also bring a unique depth to the design.

3. Updating the band material:

Switching the band material of an engagement ring is an easy way to enhance its look without altering the centre stone. For example, upgrading to a platinum band can add durability and a modern touch. 

For those wanting more sparkle, intricate designs, or pavé diamonds on the band can elevate its elegance. Choosing a new band material can modernise and strengthen the ring for everyday wear.

4. A new diamond shape:

Changing the diamond shape in your engagement ring is another popular upgrade option. This lets you personalise the piece while keeping the original setting. Rings are available in various cuts, from traditional rounds to unique fancy shapes.

Altering the shape can transform both the aesthetic and emotional resonance of the ring. You can align it with contemporary trends or personal tastes while retaining the existing sentimental connection. This balance offers a perfect blend of new and old.

5: Adding accent stones:

Adding accent stones is a versatile way to upgrade an engagement ring. These smaller diamonds or gems can increase sparkle and create a more intricate design. You can position them along the band or beside the main stone to enhance its beauty and draw the eye. 

Consider colored gemstones like sapphires, rubies, or emeralds for a personalised touch. Upgrading with accent stones can transform the ring into a modern halo, three-stone, or sidestone style. Swapping colourless stones for vibrant ones adds a pop of colour, making your ring really stand out.

Celebrating the past, embracing the future 

Upgrading your engagement ring is more than just a style decision: it’s a deeply personal journey that beautifully blends tradition with new beginnings. 

Whether you’re marking a milestone, refreshing your ring to reflect changing tastes, or incorporating new design elements, the process allows you to blend the sentimental value of your original piece with the excitement of something new that reflects the past and welcomes the future.


​
Disclaimer: this is a collaborative post.